Recently in an effort to rid myself of some things I will never use again, I took many of my old CDs to our local music store and traded them in. Most of my CDs are from when I was in 8th and 9th grade, when two things were true: 1: CDs were still the primary method for music, and 2: my music taste was terrrrible. Just terrible. Obviously I didn't think so at the time, but consider: the CDs I took to the store included such luminaries as Puddle of Mudd's Come Clean, Velvet Revolver's Libertad and highlighted (or lowlighted) by Buckcherry's 15, which amazingly was my favorite album when I was in 8th grade.
In the interests of reliving the past I listened through 15 on the way to the music store. And dear god is it awful. It's mind-bogglingly bad. The lyrics range from the wonderfully nonsensical ("I guess a music man is no shelter from the rain") to the pointlessly attention-seeking ("you're crazy but I like the way you fuck me" may be the least subtle lyric of all time). The music includes ill-advised stabs at country, generic radio-friendly ballads, and post-punk(not that these guys know what post-punk is; it's mostly just growling and palm-muted guitars), and frontman Josh Todd appears to believe he's Mick Jagger (he's not, if you were holding out hope).
The point of all that is: this was my favorite band at one point. This was an album I considered life-changing! It's intesting to me that something so bad can provide an important foundation. Of course, everyone always considers their music taste good, so I can't really claim that what I like now is any better... but I'm pretty sure it is. But besides thinking it's better, that summer when I bought 15 was the first time I really got into music of my own, and now it's become a very important part of my life. It's just funny that it all started with music that was so terrible.
A blog that can only hope to be as good at reviewing music as Jeff Ament is at wearing hats.
Thursday, November 20, 2014
Thursday, October 23, 2014
The Best Album of Each Year Part 4: 2003-2014
The White Stripes, Elephant
Why it’s the best: Because the White Stripes perfected a formula that has never successfully been replicated--even by Jack White himself. Sure, there have been plenty of blues/rock bands--even two-man blues/rock bands (the Black Keys come to mind)--but none have tackled the genre quite like Jack and Meg White. The fusion of Jack's technically proficient guitar playing with Meg's deceptively simple beats created an entirely unique sound, all infused with a sense of childlike wonder (on songs like "Black Math" and "I Want to be the Boy to Warm Your Mother's Heart.")
Other candidates: Radiohead’s Hail to the Thief, The Strokes' Room on Fire
Quality of year (out of 10): 8
Quality of year (out of 10): 8
Arcade Fire, Funeral
Why it’s the best: Because rarely does a band arrive as fully formed and unique as Arcade Fire. With songs that are about death and yet also about life, Arcade Fire debuted with four songs about their childhood neighborhoods (or a version of them), and also delved into topics like riding in the backseat of a car, and the ancestral home of band member Regine de Chassagne's family ("Haiti"). The album rides from one high to the next. It's fitting that "Wake Up" was later used to score Spike Jonze's film version of Where the Wild Things Are, because few songs convey that sense of childlike wonderment as well as Arcade Fire do here. (In fact, the only band that comes close is the previous band on this list, the White Stripes.)
Other candidates: Interpol’s Antics, The Black Keys' Rubber Factory
Quality of year: 6
Quality of year: 6
The National, Alligator
Why it’s the best: Because this is where the National arrived, and it's the first step towards greatness for a band that would continue down that path with each subsequent release. It's actually a bit weird to go back to this one; it's strange hearing Matt Berninger sound as young as he does here, because he's become so associated with that middle-aged baritone voice he has now. This album is also the most upbeat of their catalog by far-- there are honest-to-god punk rockers on here! ("Abel," "Lit Up")
Other candidates: My Morning Jacket's Z, Spoon's Gimme Fiction
Quality of year: 6
The Decemberists, The Crane Wife
Why it’s the best: Because this album has ten- and twelve-minute songs, song versions of Shakespeare plays and Japanese folk tales, and yet it succeeds, and not in spite of those elements, but because of them. To ask the Decemberists to cut down on these aspects of the band would be to remove their charm and the very things that make them unique. Few can tell a story in song form like Colin Meloy, and if he wants that story to be a three-part epic about marrying a bird, then that's what it should be.
Other candidates: Silversun Pickups' Carnavas, Justin Timberlake's FutureSex/LoveSounds
Quality of year: 6
Radiohead, In Rainbows
Why it’s the best: Because some albums are more like a collection of short stories--a series of songs that, while they may be great, are unconnected except for the artist. Other albums are more like novels, with each song acting as part of a whole. This is one of those albums. Radiohead makes the sound work for them on In Rainbows, utilizing reverb beatuifully and eschewing traditional verse/chorus forms of songwriting for slow builds that, when they crescendo, lead to breathtaking moments.
Other candidates: Spoon’s Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga, The National's Boxer
Quality of year: 10
Vampire Weekend, Vampire Weekend
Why it’s the best: Because this may be the happiest music I've ever heard. There are so many quirks that make Vampire Weekend's self-titled debut so good, and while it has its share of detractors, how can they turn down music that's this happy?
Other candidates: Fleet Foxes' self-titled debut, TV on the Radio's Dear Science
Quality of year: 5
Phoenix, Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix
Why it’s the best: Because this album surprised me when I first heard it; I had heard the singles, "Lisztomania" and "1901," and I liked them, but I wasn't sure it would necessarily mean that the album would be great. I was wrong; it's great all the way through, even succeeding in a two-part instrumental.
Other candidates: The XX's XX, AFI's Crash Love
Quality of year: 1
The National, High Violet
Why it’s the best: Because this album was where the National got grand, bringing in common "we're rock star now" cliche instruments like strings-- yet it wasn't overblown or pretentious, it just accented their music very well, and with it, they made their best album to date, which is doubly impressive considering how consistently great these guys are.
Other candidates: LCD Soundsystem's This is Happening, Arcade Fire's The Suburbs
Quality of year: 9
The Decemberists, The King Is Dead
Why it’s the best: Because here the Decemberists proved they were just as good at Americana and folk rock as they were with the French-inspired accordion-driven music of their previous albums. To be honest, this wouldn't have been my choice as album of the year at the time (and was rarely included in such lists from music publications), but as time has gone on, its brilliance has become more obvious to me. Colin Meloy's lyrics have always been the not-exactly-secret weapon for the Decemberists, and though he's stopped using the ridiculously big words he indulged in in the past, this may be his best work lyrically. Songs like "Don't Carry It All" and "All Arise" make you feel like you're living among 1800s pioneers, while "June Hymn" and "January Hymn" paint perfect portraits of their seasons.
Other candidates: Beirut's The Rip Tide, Fleet Foxes' Helplessness Blues
Quality of year: 9
Japandroids, Celebration Rock
Why it’s the best: Because it's very impressive that two guys can make music this loud, this powerful, all on their own. Few bands can aspire to the kind of fist-pumping anthems like "The House That Heaven Built."
Other candidates: Grizzly Bear’s Shields, Tame Impala's Lonerism
Quality of year: 1
Vampire Weekend, Modern Vampires of the City
Why it’s the best: Because this is the album where Vampire Weekend improved in areas where they already excelled, while ditching certain aspects that many found irritating. While their first album was brilliant, only this more mature version of Vampire Weekend could take a song like "Hannah Hunt," which starts off as a simple piano ballad, and take it to its impressive, piano-led crescendo.
Other candidates: Queens of the Stone Age's ...Like Clockwork, Daft Punk's Random Access Memories
Quality of year: 9
Spoon, They Want My Soul
Why it’s the best: Because this is far from the only year Spoon has an argument for having the best album of the year. 2002's Kill the Moonlight and 2007's Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga, in particular, are probably stronger than They Want My Soul, but this is the year when everything lined up just right for Spoon. At least, for now-- we still have two and a half more months for a contender to emerge.
Other candidates: Wye Oak's Shriek, St. Vincent's self-titled album
Quality of year: 5
Sunday, October 5, 2014
The Best Album of Every Year, Part 3: 1992-2002
Part 3 in the series, now with pictures!
Rage Against the Machine, Rage
Against the Machine
Why it’s the best: Because
despite what Limp Bizkit showed us, rap and metal don’t always have to combine
to be awful. The trouble was that none of those late '90s nu metal groups went about it the same way as RATM, who combined technical mastery with driven anger, and relied heavily on Tom Morello's brilliant guitar riffs.
Other candidates: REM's Automatic for the People, Neil Young's Harvest Moon
Quality of year: 4
Quality of year: 4
Pearl Jam, Vs.
Why it’s the best: Because Pearl
Jam is the best. But seriously, for me there are two reasons why Vs. beats out In Utero: first, because musically In Utero is a bit of a step down from Nevermind, while Vs. is an improvement over Ten-- it's less grim and overdramatic; and second, In Utero was clearly Nirvana trying to make a statement, bringing in Steve Albini to record a rougher, less radio-friendly album, while Pearl Jam was simply making an album with little regard to how it would be perceived (or at least, not nearly as much overt regard as Nirvana), and that tends to hold up better over time.
Other candidates: Nirvana’s In
Utero, Smashing Pumpkins' Siamese Dream
Quality of year: 6
Quality of year: 6
Pearl Jam, Vitalogy
Why it’s the best: Because it's the best album of one of the best and most influential bands of the '90s. Vitalogy features one classic song after another; from "Corduroy" to "Last Exit" to "Better Man," if you're looking for the best Pearl Jam songs, nearly this entire album qualifies.
Other candidates: Weezer's Blue Album, Alice In Chains' Jar of Flies
Quality of year: 7
Quality of year: 7
Radiohead, The Bends
Why it’s the best: Because it takes the concept of Britpop to another level. Maybe it's because I'm not British, but I don't "get" Britpop; to me, It just seems like unending lesser incarnations of the Beatles. But I wouldn't have and problems with Oasis or Blur if they sounded like Radiohead does on The Bends. The amazing thing is, this album only hinted at Radiohead's potential.
Other candidates: Pulp’s
Different Class, Neil Young's Mirror Ball
Quality of year: 1
Pearl Jam, No Code
Why it’s the best: Because there weren't a lot of candidates for '96, and because I am a bit biased when it comes to Pearl Jam. But in all seriousness, No Code does make an excellent case as the best album of 1996; it's another step in the direction they started taking with Vitalogy, a more risk-taking and diverse approached that took them from the African drumbeats of "Who You Are" to the rock harmonica-driven "Smile" while still sounding entirely cohesive--no small feat.
Other candidates: Soundgarden's Down on the Upside, Rage Against the Machine's Evil Empire
Quality of year: 3
Quality of year: 3
Radiohead, OK Computer
Why it’s the best: Because it's hard to find a year when this wouldn't win. That being said, it does feel especially suited to the late '90s in its themes, which deal with the rapid rise in technology, alien abductions, and
Other candidates: Daft Punk’s
Homework, Yo La Tengo's I Can Hear the Heart Beating As One
Quality of year: 4
Quality of year: 4
Neutral Milk Hotel, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
Why it’s the best: Because this melancholy album ushered in the indie movement of the 2000s. It may not be for everyone, but there's no denying that Jeff Mangum's songwriting is top-notch, even if his voice can be... difficult... to listen to.
Other candidates: System of a Down's self-titled debut, Spoon's A Series of Sneaks
Quality of year: 4
Quality of year: 4
Rage Against the Machine, The
Battle of Los Angeles
Why it’s the best: 1999 was a strange time for the music industry; sales were through the roof, but quality was at a low point. Maybe Rage Against the Machine was just the band for that year, a band that didn't cash in on industry trends, but instead invented their own. Evil Empire was a slight step back from their debut, but this one is every bit as good.
Other candidates: Wilco's Summerteeth, AFI's Black Sails in the Sunset
Quality of year: 4
Radiohead, Kid A
Why it’s the best: Because no one
else could have-or would have-followed up OK Computer quite like this. Radiohead responded to the pressure of following up their masterpiece by creating another masterpiece, one that is completely different and yet still unmistakably Radiohead.
Other candidates: Queens of the Stone Age's Rated R, Outkast's Stankonia
Quality of year: 7
The Strokes, Is This It
Why it’s the best: Because the only way to deliver on the hype that the Strokes were getting in 2001 was for the music to be this good. The word always used to describe the Strokes is "effortless," and rightly so: they seemed effortlessly cool, both in appearance and in sound. But don't be fooled: these songs are meticulously crafted and expertly carried out by brilliant musicians.
Other candidates: The White
Stripes’ White Blood Cells, Muse's Origin of Symmetry
Quality of year: 10
Queens of the Stone Age, Songs
for the Deaf
Why it’s the best: Because it's metal that appeals even to non-metal fans. It's a very diverse album, encompassing everything from good pop-rock music "Go with the Flow" to screaming metal "Six Shooter," and handles each genre it tackles as well as any band I've heard.
Other candidates: Spoon’s Kill
the Moonlight, The Decemberists' Castaways and Cutouts
Quality of year: 8
Quality of year: 8
Monday, September 22, 2014
The Best Album of Every Year Part 2: 1981-1991
Part 2 of the feature I spent way too much time on: the best albums of every year. Here's 1981-1991:
1981
Elvis Costello's Trust
Why it’s the best: Because Elvis
Costello started out his career on fire, just like Led Zeppelin. Five great
albums in five years—few artists can boast such a claim, but Elvis Costello
can, and even more incredibly, they were the first five albums of his career.
Other candidates: The Clash’s
Sandinista!,
Quality of year (out of 10): 1
Quality of year (out of 10): 1
1982
Michael Jackson's Thriller
Why it’s the best: Because it’s
the best that pop has ever been, and possibly the best it ever will be. Thriller remains unsurpassed as a pop album, the modern definition of which usually consists of multiple radio hit singles and some filler to make it an album-length. Not so with Thriller, which is basically an entire album's worth of hit singles; all these songs still get regular radio play today, and with good reason.
Other candidates: The Clash’s
Combat Rock, Elvis Costello's Imperial Bedroom
Quality of year: 4
Quality of year: 4
1983
David Bowie's Let's Dance
Why it’s the best: This may not be Bowie's best, but anything he does has the opportunity to be the best album of its year. This also isn't the most popular Bowie album among fans; many at the time saw it as a bit of a sell-out. In reality it's not that, while it's also not quite up to the standards of his '70s work. And if you're OK with that, this is a worthwhile Bowie album that features several of his very best songs.
Other candidates: The Police's Synchronicity, New Order's Power Corruption and Lies
Quality of year: 7
1984
Metallica's Ride the Lightning
Why it’s the best: Because the
genre of metal we know today wouldn’t exist without it—and it’s still better
than almost anything being put out by current bands. Metallica aren’t simply an
influence on metal bands; they remain the band that every metal band is still
trying to match.
Other candidates: U2's The Unforgettable Fire, The Replacements' Let It Be
Quality of year: 3
1985
Tears for Fears's Songs from the
Big Chair
Why it’s the best: Because it
sums up the ‘80s in a way no other album can. With some of the best tracks of the entire decade ("Head over Heels," "Everybody Wants to Rule the World")
Other candidates: The Smiths’
Meat Is Murder, The Cure's The Head on the Door
Quality of year: 6
1986
The Smiths' The Queen Is Dead
Why it’s the best: Because a Smiths album had to get on here at some point; they were just that good. In spite of their overly '80s production, the Smiths are in my opinion the best band of the '80s, and either this or Meat Is Murder is their best work. This one features Morrisey's lyrics at their most complex, and while it lacks that one classic song in the vein of "How Soon Is Now?" it's the most complete Smiths album.
Other candidates: Metallica's Master of Puppets, Paul Simon's Graceland
Quality of year: 6
1987
U2's The Joshua Tree
Why it’s the best: Because this
is the one where it all clicked for U2. This album manages to be grand in the best possible ways, without sounding pretentious like some of their later work. Love them or hate them (and there are many on both sides of that argument) you can't deny that intro to "Where the Streets Have No Name."
Other candidates: REM's Document, New Order's Brotherhood
Quality of year: 8
1988
Michael Jackson's Bad
Why it’s the best: Because Michael's arguably the best pop singer ever, meaning Thriller isn't all he has to offer. Bad features "The Way You Make Me Feel" and other classic songs, and while it's not quite Thriller, nothing really is.
Other candidates: Metallica's ...And Justice for All
Quality of year: 2
1989
Tom Petty's Full Moon Fever
Why it’s the best: Because of "Free Fallin," "I Won't Back Down," and "Running Down a Dream." There are other reasons, but shouldn't that be enough?
Other candidates: Nirvana's Bleach, The Cure's Disintegration
Quality of year: 2
1990
Pixies' Bossanova
Why it’s the best: Because while 1990 was an especially weak year for music--coming in the middle of the transition of the '80s and '90s--but the Pixies were the most important band of that time period, and Bossanova is very representative of their sound.
Other candidates: Neil Young’s
Ragged Glory, AC/DC's The Razor's Edge
Quality of year: 1
1991
Nirvana's Nevermind
Why it’s the best: Because the
rest of the ‘90s couldn’t have happened without it. As much as I wanted to pick Pearl Jam's Ten for this spot, I couldn’t choose anything other than Nevermind for 1991. It
just wouldn’t be right. Besides, I've already given Pearl Jam too many spots in part 3 (coming later this week!)
Other
candidates: Ten, REM's Out of TimeQuality of year: 9
Monday, September 8, 2014
The Best Album of Every Year Part 1: 1970-1980
My last album review, Spoon’s They Want My Soul, got me thinking
of a larger project. I think They Want My Soul is the best album of the year so
far, and it got me thinking about the best album of each year going back. This
idea snowballed, and here we are: my list of the best album of every year.
Since the '60s were dominated by singles, with very few acts
making great full-length albums until the very end of the decade, this list
will start with 1970. The criteria considered are as follows: how the album was
received and its popularity at that time; its influence for future music (which
obviously won't apply for the most recent years); how well the album holds up
today; and of course, my own personal taste, because that can't be avoided. It
should be noted also that these albums will almost exclusively fall in the
rock/alternative genres, because that is what this blog covers. I've also rated the overall strength of each year on a scale of 10 (10 being the highest), because not all years deliver the same amount of great albums. Yeah, I spent way too much time on this. On to the
list...
1970
Black Sabbath, Paranoid
Why it’s the best: Because it’s
the album that basically invented metal. Before Ozzy rode the Crazy Train and
started eating bats and writing controversy-generating songs about the “suicide solution,” he was a key
member of a pioneering group. Every metal band today has these guys, and this
album, to thank for its existence.
Other candidates: Led Zeppelin
III, Neil Young’s After the Gold Rush
Strength of year: (out of 10) 6
Strength of year: (out of 10) 6
1971
Led Zeppelin, Led Zeppelin IV
Why it’s the best: Because it’s
hard to top perfection. While no album is perfect, is there anything more you could really ask from Led Zeppelin IV? You might think there is, but if that happens, just put on "Black Dog." And know that it couldn't possibly be any better.
Other candidates: Marvin Gaye’s
What’s Going On, The Rolling Stones’ Sticky Fingers
Strength of year: 10
1972
David Bowie, The Rise and Fall of
Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars
Why it’s the best: Because
convoluted storylines don’t matter when the writing is as good as this. Other
than an ill-advised cover of the Kinks’ “It Ain’t Easy,” this album is nearly
flawless; it hits all the right notes, from the all-time great key change in
“Soul Love” to the singalong ending of “Starman” to the undeniable “Suffragette
City,” this album is the best the ‘70s had to offer.
Other candidates: The Rolling
Stones’ Exile on Main Street, Stevie Wonder’s Talking Book
Strength of year: 8
1973
Led Zeppelin, Houses of the Holy
Why it’s the best: Because Led
Zeppelin were in the middle of one of the greatest runs of albums ever. Houses
of the Holy was simply the latest in a long line of incredible albums from this
band. And though Robert Plant’s voice had started to falter a bit by now (he
sounds like a shell of himself on opening track “The Song Remains the Same,”) at
other points he sounds like vintage Plant, like on “Over the Hills and Far
Away.” This album is sort of a transition for Zeppelin; it’s the first sign of
the ideas that would eventually derail them (as seen here on “The Crunge”), but
also one of the last vestiges of greatness from a band that, at its peak, was
better than any other.
Other candidates: Pink Floyd’s
Dark Side of the Moon, Iggy and the Stooges’ Raw Power
Strength of year: 6
1974
Aerosmith, Get Your Wings
Why it’s the best: Because it was
the best Rolling Stones album released in 1974. The Stones’ albums in the early
‘70s spawned a lot of imitators, none of whom became as successful as Aerosmith. This album doesn't really have any of their hits, but it's the best from back to front, highlighted by "Same Old Song and Dance" and "Seasons of Wither."
Other candidates: David Bowie’s
Diamond Dogs, Rush's self-titled debut
Strength of year: 2
1975
Bruce Springsteen, Born to Run
Why it’s the best: Because it’s
the greatest epic album in history. The songs of Born to Run are true epics,
telling stories of ordinary Americans in typical Springsteen style, but the
instrumentation makes each story sound like the most important thing in the
world.
Other candidates: Fleetwood Mac’s
self-titled album, Led Zeppelin’s Physical Graffiti
Strength of year: 7
1976
Boston, Boston
Why it’s the best: Because it’s
the best of what made classic rock great. Still one of the best debut albums
ever released, Boston was the product of years of studio tinkering by their
talented guitarist and mastermind Tom Schultz. But what really put Boston over
the top is Brad Delp’s voice, which reaches heights impossible for nearly
everyone.
Other candidates: Thin Lizzy’s
Jailbreak, The Ramones’ self-titled album
Strength of year: 5
1977
Fleetwood Mac, Rumours
Why it’s the best: Because it’s
the best product a terrible relationship’s end has ever produced. Rumours goes from one classic song to the next like few albums can. Ask anyone from the era--they don't just remember "Go Your Own Way;" they know "Never Going Back Again," "You Make Loving Fun," and "Gold Dust Woman" just as well.
Other candidates: Elvis Costello’s
My Aim Is True, Television’s Marquee Moon
Strength of year: 10
1978
Blondie, Parallel Lines
Why it’s the best: Because it’s a
great pop record, from back when that sort of thing could actually exist. A band that made its name at CBGB could only record a song like "Heart of Glass" and get away with it if it was this good. But that's hardly all Parallel Lines has to offer; from the guitar-driven "One Way or Another" to the dreamy "Fade Away and Radiate" to the fast-paced "Just Go Away," this album is great from first to last.
Other candidates: Elvis
Costello’s This Year’s Model, Bruce Springsteen’s Darkness on the Edge of Town
Strength of year: 7
1979
Elvis Costello, Armed Forces
Why it’s the best: Because Elvis
Costello is seriously terrific, and any of his albums from this era could be
the album of the year. While My Aim Is True might be his best, it sounds like the '50s, while Armed Forces is
the one where he really developed his signature style.
Other candidates: Joy Division’s
Unknown Pleasures, Blondie's Eat to the Beat
Strength of year: 8
1980
Joy Division, Closer
Why it’s the best: Because Joy
Division was the band that ushered in the ‘80s. Often mimicked but never really
replicated, the minimalist sound of this band is impressive and yes, sad, and
“Isolation” showed what would happen if you combined punk with synthesizers.
Other candidates: Talking Heads’
Remain in Light, The Clash’s London Calling
Strength of year: 7
Strength of year: 7
Tuesday, August 19, 2014
Spoon: They Want My Soul
Spoon's 2010 album Transference was an oddball of an album. It seemed like a reaction to the easy catchiness of their previous effort, 2007's fantastic Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga. Transference zigged where you expected it to zag, and was full of unexpected stops and starts. It was well enough reviewed when it was initially released, but opinion seems to have turned on Transference since then, with many early reviews of Spoon's latest album, They Want My Soul, hailing it as a return to form for the band after a previous misstep.
And while Transference wasn't bad, there's no denying that Soul takes after Ga Ga Go Ga Ga, with its catchy melodies and production sheen. There are plenty of similarities to be drawn between those two albums: they are mostly the same length (37 minutes vs. 36), the same number of songs (10), and once again Spoon displays the same knack for infectious songwriting.
The album kicks off with rocker "Rent I Pay," which comes out of the gate with a hard-hitting drumbeat courtesy of the great Jim Eno. It's followed by "Inside Out," which is full of empty space and seems content to just let its programmed beat and keyboards wash over you for five minutes. "Do You" is the obvious highlight, a song reminiscent of great Spoon singles of the past like "The Underdog" or" I Turn My Camera On" in its catchiness and in the immediate impact it makes on the listener.
And that's perhaps the most apt description for They Want My Soul: immediate. Following up an album that seemed almost a little too concerned with defying the expectations of the listener, Spoon has abandoned that approach for one that's closer to hitting the listener in the face and saying "hey look, a great Spoon song."
It's hard to believe Spoon has been doing this for nearly 20 years, and even harder to believe that, almost 20 years in, they've crafted one of their best albums to date. It's not quite Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga or Kill the Moonlight, but it certainly belongs in the discussion.
Grade: A
Monday, August 4, 2014
The Radio Is Irrelevant
Earlier this week, I was on YouTube, listening to a song
that had been popular a few years back, “Move Along” by the All-American
Rejects. (This is not something I’d normally be listening to, it just got in my
head that day… anyway…) The top comment for the song struck me as odd. It said
“I love this song! I miss hearing it all the time!”
Clearly he or she was referring to the days when the
All-American Rejects were extremely popular on the radio. The main reason I
found this comment odd is because this person was listening to this song on
YouTube, which means he or she can, in fact, hear it all the time. It’s on the
internet! For free! You can hear it as much or as little as you like!
This brings me to my topic, the irrelevance of the radio.
Radio stations were once the only way of discovering new artists, or really of
hearing any music that you or your friends did not own. Being played on the
radio was once the goal of any artist hoping to become popular and grow an
audience. However, so much has changed today that this is no longer imperative,
or even important, for a new artist.
Take, for example,
High Violet, a 2010 album by The
National. The National, for those unaware, are a highly critically praised
indie rock band, known for sad songs and their frontman’s deep baritone. Hardly
Top 40 fare. Yet High Violet debuted
on the Billboard 100 at #3, shattering their previous highest place on the
chart by 63 places.
In the past,
success of an album largely hinged on the strength of its radio singles. So how
did the singles for High Violet do?
Well, the only single from High Violet
was “Bloodbuzz Ohio,” released four months before the album. “Bloodbuzz Ohio’s”
highest position on the charts? Sixteenth, and that was in Belgium. The song
failed to chart at all in the United States, getting little airplay even from
rock stations.
So how to account
for the increased sales of High Violet?
Start with the fact that “Bloodbuzz Ohio” was available for months before the
release of the album on iTunes, YouTube, Pandora, The National’s own website,
and a myriad of other online music sites. It received positive reviews from
online music reviewers, being voted “best new music” by indie heavyweights
Pitchfork Media. This positive press, coupled with the widespread availability
of the song, was the most significant factor in High Violet’s sales.
The internet is
what has changed all of this. There are now so many different ways of hearing a
new song or album that the radio is just not nearly as important as it used to
be. These days when a band comes out with a new song, they generally post it to
their website. Soon a video is posted to YouTube, and the song goes up for sale
on iTunes and for streaming on Spotify. This is the way most people now find
out about new music, and all these people have already heard the song before
radio stations even get hold of it.
So we don’t need the radio for music discovery anymore. What
does that leave? Radio stations are now most played in cars and in stores. Yet
even this is declining. Many cars now come with Sirius radio, which is more
split up by genre, and stores have access to Sirius as well as Pandora. The
majority of cars now also come with a hookup for an iPod, or a CD player at the
very least.
The radio will likely always be used by people who want to
hear some tunes on the way back from work, and don’t really care what they are.
But for those serious about music, there are a host of more viable, and more
convenient, options for discovering and hearing music. So, to the person who
commented on that YouTube video, never fear. You can listen to “Move Along” any
time you want.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)